Can you spot the difference?
Artificial intelligence has reached astonishing levels of sophistication, producing art, writing, and music that often rival human creations. Tools like MidJourney, ChatGPT, and DALL·E can replicate styles, invent narratives, and craft visuals with shocking precision. But are they truly creative—or just mimicking human ingenuity?
Today, we’ll dive into real examples of AI vs human creations in writing, art, and ideas. Your mission: guess which is which. Along the way, we’ll explore what sets human creativity apart. Ready? Let’s begin!
Round 1: AI vs Human Writing
Which one feels more human?
Example A
“A lone figure stood on the bridge. Behind her, the glowing dawn hugged the silouette of the cityscape. The world slowly came back to life, and the chaos of the buzzling city felt distant. This moment was a reminder of all the beauty hidden in silence. “
Example B
“As the sun rose, its warm light illuminated the buildings, casting long shadows that danced on the pavement. The city began to hum with life, a rhythmic pulse of footsteps, cars, and distant voices—a tapestry of movement painted by the arrival of day.”
Your Guess: Which one is human?
Answer:
Example A was written by me, while Example B was generated by ChatGPT. Notice how the AI sticks to predictable phrasing and balanced structure, while the human-written piece takes risks with tone and rhythm to evoke emotion.
Round 2: AI vs Human Artwork
Can you spot the AI creation?
Below are two images. Take a close look at the details:
- Image A: A serene forest with a glowing sunset
- Image B: A futuristic cityscape with neon lights and flying cars.
Your Guess: Which one is AI-generated?
Answer:
Image B was created using MidJourney. AI often excels at generating “perfect” visuals but struggles with subtleties like natural lighting and realistic imperfections. The human-created forest scene has an organic quality that feels more grounded.
Round 3: AI vs Human Ideas
Which idea feels more unique?
Idea 1:
It is a story about a brave gnome girl named Twilby, who discovers the Heartstone of her magical forest is fading. With her friends—a mouse, a squirrel, and a wise owl—she embarks on a journey to solve the problem.
Idea 2:
A product concept for a smart mirror that not only tracks your fitness goals but also suggests outfits based on your calendar and weather.
Your Guess: Which one came from an AI?
Answer:
Idea 2 was generated by ChatGPT, while Idea 1 was brainstormed by me. While AI can suggest highly practical ideas, human creativity often stems from abstract thinking or deeply personal experiences, lending an unpredictable, imaginative quality.
Why This Matters
AI tools are very impressive, and get better by the minute. They mimic patterns, analyze data, and produce content that feels human. But hopefully, this post shows, that they are not comparable with human creativity, at least not yet.
Did any of these examples fool you? Which rounds were easiest—and hardest—for you to spot the AI? Share your thoughts in the comments—I’d love to hear how you did!
At the end of the day, AI can be a powerful tool for creativity, but it’s our humanity that is the true spark of innovation, and AI should always just be a creative companion, not the creative.
Why not share this post with a friend and challenge them to spot the AI, too? Let’s see how sharp their eye is!
